20 Best Mystery Boxes for Women
There's an undeniable magic to getting a surprise gift, especially one you treat yourself to! ✨ Mystery boxes perfectly capture that thrill, offering a curated bundle of joy delivered right to your door. 💌 With so many options out there, finding the right one can be overwhelming. This guide breaks down the best of the best, perfect for gifting or for treating yourself. From unique collectibles to luxury self-care, there’s a box here for every woman! For a great overview, you can always check out this guide to the best mystery boxes, and for some truly unique finds, the PlushThis Mystery Box collection is where the adventure begins! 🎁
Our Top Picks: Alternative & Collectible Mystery Boxes 🦇
Beyond the usual beauty and fashion boxes lies a world of enchanting collectibles perfect for self-expression. A thoughtfully chosen plush isn't just a toy; it's a piece of art that tells a story about your unique style. For the woman who embraces darker aesthetics or a touch of alternative charm, these collector's mystery boxes are a perfect way to build a collection that's truly one-of-a-kind. It's a fun category to explore, and you can see even more options in this guide to the best toy subscription boxes.
1. Dark Aesthetic Mystery Box Plush & Accessories 5-Piece Set
Curate your own darkly charming aesthetic with this five-piece set. It’s your all-in-one starter kit for a touch of elegant gloom, featuring two stunningly spooky plushies and three matching accessories. Perfect for adding a bit of moody magic to your desk, bookshelf, or creative space.
Pros:
- Comes packed with two plushies and three surprise accessories.
- Perfect for anyone who loves dark aesthetic, goth, and emo styles.
- Every item is carefully selected and guaranteed to be high-quality.
- Makes a great and exciting surprise gift for any occasion.
Cons:
- The exact items are a surprise; specific contents cannot be chosen.
Prices: $59.99
2. 29.99USD Plush Mystery Box
Ready for a high-value treat? This box delivers three gorgeous, small-sized plushies right to your door, offering a delightful surprise from our most beloved collections. It’s a fantastic opportunity to snag a potential online exclusive and add a dash of unexpected joy to your day.
Pros:
- A perfect and unique surprise gift for her, or a special treat for yourself.
- Includes a mix from unique Goth, Kawaii, and other collections.
- Chance to own exclusive, never-before-released online designs.
- An exciting way to build a chic and diverse collection.
Cons:
- You cannot choose the specific plushies you will receive inside.
Prices $29.99
3. 19.99USD Plush Mystery Box
Discover the perfect sweet spot between surprise and value. Inside, you'll find two or three wonderful plush toys, each crafted from irresistibly soft, top-notch materials. It’s an ideal way to experience the magic of our Goth and Kawaii collections without breaking the bank.
Pros:
- A great mix of designs from the Kawaii and Goth collections.
- Every plush is guaranteed to be made of top-notch materials.
- An affordable way to start a unique and wonderful plush collection.
- Makes an exciting and easy surprise gift for any collector.
Cons:
- The specific plush toys you receive are chosen randomly.
Prices: $19.99
4. 9.99USD Plush Toys Mystery Box
Add a little pop of fun to your week with this budget-friendly surprise! Each box holds one or two adorable plush companions, crafted from premium, fluffy materials. It’s a small price for a big smile, making it the perfect pick-me-up or a cute gift for a friend.
Pros:- The most affordable way to experience the thrill of mystery boxes.
- Made of premium materials, ensuring a soft and fluffy texture.
- A perfect, budget-friendly surprise gift for a friend or yourself.
- A random selection of cute creatures like bunnies, foxes, or owls.
- You may receive either one or two plushies; the quantity is random.
Prices $9.99
5. 5.99USD Plush Toys Mystery Box
The ultimate tiny treat! For less than a latte, you get one adorable, high-quality plush toy to brighten your day. Whether it becomes your new desk buddy or a charming accessory, this mini-mystery is all about simple, unexpected joy.
Pros:
- The most budget-friendly way to get a fun, surprise collectible.
- Made of high-quality materials with a soft and cuddly texture.
- A perfect, low-cost "just because" gift or stocking stuffer.
- A random toy from a collection of adorable animals.
Cons:
- You only receive one plush and cannot choose which one.
Prices $5.99
From One-Time Surprise to Monthly Delight: Plush Subscriptions 💌
Love the idea of a mystery box but want the surprise to keep on coming? A subscription box is the answer. It’s the gift that delivers a fresh dose of excitement every single month.
6. Goth Stuffed Animals Subscription Box 🖤
Elevate your aesthetic with a monthly delivery of dark elegance. This subscription isn't just about collecting; it's a ritual of unboxing four to six curated Goth treasures. Inside, you’ll find two to three magnificent stuffed animals and an equal number of chic, gothic accessories to complement your style.
Pros:
- Delivers a curated experience of dark, mysterious beauty monthly.
- Build a collection with 4-6 carefully selected Goth plushies & accessories.
- A flexible subscription you can skip or cancel at any time.
- A one-of-a-kind unboxing experience that arrives at your doorstep.
Cons:
- The mystery is part of the allure; specific items cannot be pre-selected.
Prices $69.95 for a one-time purchase; save 10% with a monthly subscription.
7. PlushThis Emo Stuffed Animals Subscription Box 🎶
Embrace your feels with a box that understands. Every month delivers a curated package of four to six items designed for heartfelt self-expression. You'll receive two to three beautifully moody Emo stuffed animals and a selection of matching Emo-style accessories that speak to the soul.
Pros:
- A great monthly haul of two to three Emo plushies and accessories.
- Perfect for women who connect with the unique Emo aesthetic.
- A personalized experience with carefully selected, one-of-a-kind items.
- You can easily subscribe, save 10%, skip a month, or cancel anytime.
Cons:
- You cannot choose the specific stuffed animals or accessories inside.
Prices $69.95 for a one-time purchase, or subscribe for a 10% discount.
8. PlushThis Kawaii Stuffed Animals Subscription Box 💖
Unleash a monthly dose of pure happiness! This subscription is your ticket to the cheerful world of Kawaii, delivering four to six irresistibly cute items to your door. Each box is a delightful explosion of color and charm, featuring two to three adorable stuffed animals and unique Kawaii accessories.
Pros:
- A spectacular monthly surprise packed with oversized cuteness.
- Features innovative color combinations and carefully selected plush toys.
- A cost-effective way to build a diverse collection of kawaii art.
- Enjoy flexible subscription savings with options to skip or cancel.
Cons:
- The curated contents are a mystery, so specific items cannot be requested.
Prices $69.95 for a one-time purchase, or subscribe to save 10%.
For Beauty, Wellness & Beyond: More Must-Have Mystery Boxes 💄
Beyond the enchanting world of plushies, there are so many other amazing boxes perfect for discovering new favorites in beauty, wellness, and fashion. Here are some top-rated options!
9. FabFitFun Box 💅🛍️
This is one of the most popular subscription boxes for a reason! It's a quarterly box absolutely packed with full-sized products across beauty, fitness, wellness, and home. The value is incredible, and you can even customize some of the items yourself. It feels like Christmas four times a year! 🎄
10. IPSY (formerly BoxyCharm) ✨
For the absolute makeup lover, IPSY is a dream come true. 💖 Depending on your subscription level, you'll receive a personalized mix of deluxe samples and full-sized beauty products each month. It's a fantastic and affordable way to try out new brands and trending products without breaking the bank.
11. Allure Beauty Box 💋
Curated by the editors of Allure magazine, this box is known for its high-quality, expert-tested product selections. You'll get a mix of luxury and indie brands, with at least three full-sized items in every delivery. It’s perfect for the discerning beauty enthusiast who loves being in the know.
12. Curateur (by Rachel Zoe) 👠👜
For a touch of true luxury, Curateur is the answer. This quarterly box, curated by celebrity stylist Rachel Zoe, includes high-end fashion, accessories, and beauty items. It's a premium experience that feels like having your own personal stylist send you a care package.
13. TheraBox 🧘♀️🛀
This is the ultimate self-care subscription box, designed to make you feel pampered and happy. Each box is curated by therapists and includes a therapeutic activity plus 6-8 full-sized wellness goodies for your mind, body, and soul. Think aromatherapy, bath products, journals, and more!
14. Sips by ☕
For the tea lover, this is the perfect monthly treat. Based on a personalized quiz, Sips by sends you four different types of tea to try each month, making over 16 cups. It's a wonderful way to discover new blends and amazing brands from around the world. 🍵
15. Book of the Month 📚
A book lover's dream! Each month, you get to choose one book from a curated selection of five new and early-release titles. It takes the guesswork out of finding your next great read and often features amazing debut authors. It's the perfect excuse to curl up and relax.
16. Rocksbox 💍
Why buy when you can borrow? Rocksbox is a jewelry rental subscription that lets you experiment with new styles. You get a set of three beautiful pieces of jewelry to wear as much as you want. When you're ready for something new, just send them back for a new set. If you fall in love with a piece, you can buy it at a discount! ✨
17. Universal Yums 🍬✈️
Take a trip around the world through snacks! Every month, Universal Yums sends a box of snacks and candies from a different country, complete with a fun guidebook. It's a super fun and delicious way to experience new cultures and flavors without leaving home.
18. Once Upon a Book Club 📖🎁
This box takes reading to a whole new, immersive level. As you read the selected monthly book, you'll find prompts telling you to open specific, wrapped gifts that correspond to something happening in the story. It's a wonderfully unique experience that truly brings books to life.
19. Kinder Beauty Box 🌱🐰
For those who prefer their products to be clean, vegan, and cruelty-free, the Kinder Beauty Box is a perfect choice. You'll receive a mix of skincare, makeup, and hair care items each month that are ethically sourced, good for you, and kind to animals.
20. Pura Vida Bracelet Club 🌊
Receive a monthly delivery of three exclusive bracelets from the popular and socially-conscious brand, Pura Vida. The styles are always cute and on-trend, making them perfect for stacking. Plus, the brand is known for supporting artisans and charities worldwide, so it's a purchase you can feel good about. 💖
Tips for Gifting the Perfect Mystery Box 🎁
A mystery box is an incredible gift, but choosing the right one can make it truly unforgettable. Based on experience, here are a few tips to ensure your surprise is a huge hit!
Do Some Light Detective Work 🕵️♀️
Pay attention to the brands she already loves or follows on social media. Does she rave about a certain skincare line? Is she always showing you cute art on Instagram? These are major clues! A box that aligns with her existing tastes shows you've been paying attention and adds a thoughtful, personal touch.
Consider a "One-Off" Box First ☝️
While a full subscription is a generous gift that keeps on giving, a one-time purchase or a gift box from a subscription service is a great way to test the waters. It's less commitment and lets her experience the fun without being locked in. Many of the services listed above offer single-box options perfect for this.
Think Beyond Products to Experiences ✨
Some of the most memorable gifts aren't just things, but experiences. A box like 'Once Upon a Book Club' or a snack box from 'Universal Yums' creates a fun activity you could even do together. It’s a gift that creates a lasting memory beyond the items themselves.
Don't Forget Presentation! 🎀
Half the fun of a mystery box is the unboxing itself! If the box is being shipped to you first, consider re-wrapping it or adding a personal card. Making the reveal an event in itself adds an extra layer of thoughtfulness and excitement to the surprise.
From discovering your new favorite beauty brand to unboxing a unique piece of art, there’s a mystery box on this list to match any passion. Each one offers a wonderful opportunity to add a little extra joy and surprise to your month. And for those who believe that joy often comes in a soft, cuddly form, the world of the best stuffed animal subscription boxes is waiting to be explored!
