Rare Stuffed Animals

Welcome to our exclusive collection of Rare Stuffed Animals (or rare plushies), your destination for plush toys that stand far apart from the mass market. If you are tired of the ordinary, this is the perfect place to find your next extraordinary companion or meaningful gift.

Why are these items considered rare? Our selection is defined by unique scarcity and exceptional quality. We feature products with hard-to-find unique designs, such as elaborate gothic aesthetics, exotic animals, or custom-stitched fantasy creatures. Many of these rare plushies are crafted using special materials like vintage lace, hand-dyed fabrics, or premium faux fur. Furthermore, numerous pieces are limited-edition or come in rare color variations that are exclusive to our store, ensuring your find is truly one-of-a-kind.

This collection is carefully curated for collectors seeking high-value, unique additions, for gift seekers needing that perfect, memorable item, and for anyone who simply loves an unusual, special toy. Shop now and claim a unique piece of plush artistry that you won’t find anywhere else!

58 products

  • Stuffed black lace vampire cat
    Up to 19% off

    Vampire Goth Black Cat Plush

    From $29.99 USD
    From $29.99 USD $36.99 USD
  • purple lace goth style fennec fox
    Up to 13% off

    Goth Purple Fox Stuffed Animal

    $34.99 USD
    $34.99 USD $39.99 USD
  • Goth Black Dragon Stuffed Toy
    Up to 19% off

    Goth Black and White Dizzy Dragon Plush

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD $36.99 USD
  • Goth Voodoo, pink and black stuffed rabbit, toy that brings happiness and surprise, front view
    Up to 9% off

    Goth Voodoo Pink and Black Bunny Plush

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD $32.99 USD
  • Black unicorn plush lace fabric goth style
    Up to 19% off

    Goth Black Lace Unicorn Stuffed Animal

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD $36.99 USD
  • Goth Voodoo Blue Bunny Plush
    Up to 9% off

    Goth Voodoo Blue Bunny Plush

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD $32.99 USD
  • Goth Skeleton Unicorn Stuffed Toy
    Up to 25% off

    Goth Skeleton Unicorn Stuffed Toy

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD $39.99 USD
  • Goth Bunny Blue Voodoo Bunny
    Up to 39% off

    Arctic Blue Voodoo Goth Bunny Plush

    From $32.99 USD
    From $32.99 USD $31.99 USD
  • Goth Faceless Black Bunny Plush

    Goth Faceless Black Bunny Plush

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD $26.99 USD
  • Cute Black Devon Rex Cat Plush
    Up to 19% off

    Cute Black Devon Rex Cat Plush

    From $29.99 USD
    From $29.99 USD $36.99 USD
  • Devon Black Cat Goth Style Stuffed Toy

    Goth Devon Rex Black Cat Stuffed Animal

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD $29.99 USD
  • Stuffed pink bunny positive picture

    Pink Emo Bunny Stuffed Animal

    $32.99 USD
    $32.99 USD $32.99 USD
  • Side view of white lace fabric unicorn stuffed animal
    Up to 11% off

    Stuffed White Goth Unicorn

    $32.99 USD
    $32.99 USD $36.99 USD
  • Black Goth Crow Stuffed Toy

    Black Goth Crow Plush Toy

    From $16.99 USD
    From $16.99 USD
  • Cute pink and black plush fire dragon with heart-shaped accents

    Cute Goth Fire Dragon Plush Dusty Rose

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD
  • Glowing Ghost Stuffed Toy for Halloween

    Cute Glow-In-The-Dark Stuffed Ghost

    $22.99 USD
    $22.99 USD $22.99 USD
  • Goth Blue and Black Skeleton Unicorn Plush
    Up to 25% off

    Goth Blue and Black Skeleton Unicorn Plush

    From $29.99 USD
    From $29.99 USD $39.99 USD
  • Goth black and white two-headed stuffed cat toy
    Up to 23% off

    Goth Black And White Two-Headed Stuffed Cat

    $32.98 USD
    $32.98 USD $42.99 USD
  • Goth Pink and Black Skeleton Unicorn Plush

    Goth Pink and Black Skeleton Unicorn Plush

    From $29.99 USD
    From $29.99 USD $29.99 USD
  • Cute Goth Skeleton Cat Stuffed Toy
    Up to 30% off

    Emo Cute Skeleton Cat Plush

    $32.99 USD
    $32.99 USD $46.99 USD
  • Stuffed red and black devil Dragon plush
    Up to 19% off

    Goth Red and Black Dragon Plush

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD $36.99 USD
  • Stuffed black cat with big eyes
    Up to 19% offSold out

    Black Bombay Gothic Cat Plush

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD $36.99 USD
  • Embroidered Horror & Ghost Black Bear Plush
    Up to 32% off

    Goth Teddy Bear Case With Zip

    Low stock
    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD $43.99 USD
  • cute and kawaii Bat plush PlushThis
    Up to 11% off

    Emo Kawaii Bat Stuffed Animal

    $32.99 USD
    $32.99 USD $36.99 USD
  • Goth Voodoo Black and White Bunny Plush

    Goth Voodoo Black and White Bunny Plush

    $32.99 USD
    $32.99 USD $29.99 USD
  • Spider Black Cat Stuffed Toy
    Up to 23% offSold out

    Goth Black Cat Spider Eyes Plush

    $30.99 USD
    $30.99 USD $39.99 USD
  • Black and Blue Goth Dragon Plush

    Black and Blue Goth Dragon Plush

    $32.99 USD
    $32.99 USD
  • Pink Teddy Bear Plush Backpack
    Up to 33% off

    Cute Goth Black Pink Teddy Bear Backpack

    $32.99 USD
    $32.99 USD $48.99 USD
  • Scary pink crazy crazy bunny plush plush this

    Pink Psycho Emo Bunny Plush

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD $26.99 USD
  • Black Dragon Plush Handbag
    Up to 18% off

    Green Blue Goth Magic Dragon Plush Crossbody Bag

    $32.99 USD
    $32.99 USD $39.99 USD
  • Emo Pink Fox stuffed animal

    Kawaii Emo Pink Fennec Fox Plush

    $32.99 USD
    $32.99 USD $30.99 USD
  • Black Cyberpunk Robotic Bunny Plush

    Black Cyber Goth Bunny Plush

    Low stock
    $28.99 USD
    $28.99 USD $28.99 USD
  • Moody Purple Rose Emo Bunny stuffed animal
    Up to 19% off

    Moody Purple Rose Emo Bunny Stuffed Animal

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD $36.99 USD
  • Blue Collar Plush Toy Gift Set
    Up to 31% off

    Blue Goth Stuffed Toy Gift Set

    $72.99 USD
    $72.99 USD $105.96 USD
  • Goth Black Apple Plush
    Up to 55% off

    Goth Black Apple Plush

    From $8.99 USD
    From $8.99 USD $19.99 USD
  • Gothic Style Black Plush Dragon

    Gothic Style Black Plush Dragon

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD
  • Goss Unicorn Plush Gift Set

    Goth Unicorn Plush Gift Set

    $72.99 USD
    $72.99 USD
  • Thunderwolf x PlushThis Stuffed Animal collaboration
    Up to 33% off

    Thunderwolf Plushie Goth Black Rotating Head Wolf

    $26.99 USD
    $26.99 USD $39.99 USD
  • Pink Corn Rabbit Cosmetic Bag Plush Toy Gift Set

    Pink Vibes Plush Toy Gift Set

    $77.99 USD
    $77.99 USD
  • Dark messenger red and black bear scary plush stuffed animal stuffed animal this
    Up to 26% offSold out

    Red and Black Goth Teddy Bear

    $19.99 USD
    $19.99 USD $26.99 USD
  • Halloween Stiching Sloth Stuffed Animal

    Goth Stiching Sloth Stuffed Animal

    $32.99 USD
    $32.99 USD
  • Goth Black And Pink Baby Dragon Stuffed Animals
    Up to 15% offSold out

    Goth Black And Pink Baby Dragon Stuffed Animals

    $27.99 USD
    $27.99 USD $32.99 USD
  • Stuffed Black Imp Bunny
    Up to 11% offSold out

    Stuffed Black Goth Bunny

    $32.99 USD
    $32.99 USD $36.99 USD
  • Carsick She Dragon Tote Bag
    Sold out

    Carsick She Dragon Tote Bag

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD
  • Baby Fairy Wing Unicorn Plush
    Up to 10% offSold out

    Baby Fairy Wing Unicorn Plush

    $26.99 USD
    $26.99 USD $29.99 USD
  • Goth Pink Plush Cosmetic Bag

    Goth Pink Plush Cosmetic Bag

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD
  • Goth Brown Smirk Cat Plush
    Sold out

    Goth Brown Smirking Cat Plush

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD
  • White and red punky street art cat plush stuffed animal plush this
    Sold out

    White Voodoo Cat Stuffed Animal

    $26.99 USD
    $26.99 USD $26.99 USD